Who Are the Best for Poster Print on Demand?

Home Blog
10/04/2025

Who Are the Best Print on Demand Providers for Wall Art?

Poster Print-on-Demand Showdown: PrintShrimp vs Gelato vs Printify

If you’re selling wall art online through Etsy, Shopify, or WooCommerce, choosing the right print-on-demand (POD) partner is crucial. Three big names dominate the poster printing space: PrintShrimp, Gelato, and Printify.

In this guide, we’ll break down and compare each provider’s poster print sizes, product quality, shipping, pricing, and integrations—plus, we’ll highlight why PrintShrimp is our top pick (though we’ll be fair to all).

Poster Sizes – Global Compatibility Matters

One of the most important things for international sellers is offering poster sizes that work well for customers in both the UK/EU and the US.

PrintShrimp offers a perfectly balanced set of sizes that cater to both regions:

UK & EU Sizes:

  • A5
  • A4
  • A3
  • A2
  • A1
  • A0

US & Global Inches-Based Sizes:

  • 5×7"
  • 8×10"
  • 11×14"
  • 11×17"
  • 12×16" (30×40cm)
  • 12×18"
  • 16×20"
  • 16×24"
  • 18×24"
  • 20×28" (50×70cm)
  • 24×32"
  • 24×36"
  • 28×40" (70×100cm)
  • 30×40" (75×100cm)

This full range ensures your wall art prints can appeal to gift buyers, renters, home decor shoppers, and gallery-style collectors alike.

Gelato and Printify also offer a solid range of sizes—but selection can vary based on your chosen print provider or region. Some international customers may face limited sizing or inconsistent availability, especially on Printify where offerings differ greatly between providers.

Print Quality & Materials

All three platforms offer good-quality posters, but there are differences:

  • PrintShrimp: Posters are printed on premium 200–240gsm museum-grade paper across all regions. Consistency is guaranteed regardless of where it’s shipped from. Print quality is human-checked before dispatch for maximum quality control.
  • Gelato: Offers a decent paper quality, often around 200gsm, but exact materials may vary slightly depending on region and print partner.
  • Printify: Huge variability. Some print partners offer thick, high-end paper—others much thinner stock. You need to vet each provider manually.

If you’re building a brand known for high-quality prints, PrintShrimp’s consistency across the board gives you a big edge.

Shipping Times & Fulfillment Locations

All three companies offer global shipping, but here’s how they compare:

  • PrintShrimp: Fulfillment in the UK, US, EU, and Australia with global shipping. Orders are usually dispatched the same or next working day, ensuring lightning-fast turnaround times for your wall art and poster prints.
  • Gelato: Over 140 local partners in 32 countries, offering quick local fulfillment. Excellent for eco-conscious sellers.
  • Printify: Offers fulfillment through 90+ global partners. Speed depends on the partner. You can choose based on location, but it adds complexity.

All are solid for global delivery. PrintShrimp’s competitive edge is its balance of speed, price, and simplicity.

Pricing & Profit Margins

While prices fluctuate depending on size and shipping destination, here’s a general overview:

  • PrintShrimp: Transparent pricing with shipping included in your product cost. No subscription or hidden fees. This model allows you to maintain healthy profit margins while staying competitive on platforms like Etsy—especially for UK and EU sellers. With clean retail pricing and free shipping without cutting into your bottom line, PrintShrimp offers the best chance to succeed in the poster and wall art market.
  • Gelato: Requires Gelato+ ($24.99/mo) or Gelato Gold ($129/mo) to access 20–25% discounts. Without a plan, base prices can be higher.
  • Printify: Free to use, but Printify Premium ($29/mo) provides access to better base prices. Costs and shipping vary wildly depending on the print provider.

If you're selling lots of prints, both Gelato and Printify can offer solid profit—but PrintShrimp’s shipping-inclusive simplicity and no monthly fees make it better for most sellers, especially those scaling or testing the waters.

Integrations & Ease of Use

All three platforms integrate with major eCommerce tools:

  • PrintShrimp: Etsy, Shopify, WooCommerce (CSV import available for all other platforms)
  • Gelato: Etsy, Shopify, WooCommerce, Wix, Squarespace, BigCommerce
  • Printify: Etsy, Shopify, eBay, Wix, Walmart, WooCommerce

Printify has more integrations, but with greater complexity in choosing suppliers. PrintShrimp focuses on simplicity—perfect for sellers who want to get up and running quickly.

Support and Seller Experience

  • PrintShrimp: Live chat, email, and personal support from a small but committed team that truly understands poster businesses.
  • Gelato: Responsive support team with an extensive help center.
  • Printify: 24/7 support; however, responses may be slower during peak times due to provider coordination.

Final Thoughts: Which Is Best for Selling Posters and Wall Art?

All three print-on-demand platforms can work well for wall art sellers. But if you want:

  • A full suite of poster sizes that work in both US and UK/EU markets
  • High-quality prints on museum-grade paper
  • Simple pricing with shipping included
  • Fast, reliable global delivery
  • Personalised seller support

Then PrintShrimp is hands down the best choice for serious poster sellers.

Whether you're new to selling prints online or scaling your wall art empire, choosing a dedicated poster POD partner like PrintShrimp will save you time, boost your margins, and keep your customers happy.

Have questions about switching to PrintShrimp or want to try a test order? Get in touch—we’d love to help.